CW UPDATE: How Much is a Life Worth?
Events, Hyde Park, Politics & Labor, University of Chicago No Comments »Last year, we published a feature story about the lack of a trauma center on the South Side. Here’s an update on that issue.
Today (October 31) at 3:30pm, members of Fearless Leading by the Youth and Students for Health Equity will lead a march from 61st Street and Cottage Grove Avenue, the site of youth activist Damian Turner’s August 14, 2010 fatal shooting, to the Quad, as part of an ongoing effort to establish a South Side trauma center at the U of C Medical Center.
The event closely follows a teach-in hosted on October 20 by the two groups (along with South Side Solidarity Network), intended to educate the public about the “feasibility and necessity” of a UCMC trauma center. Turner’s memory was close at hand through the discussion, where several panel members spoke to his case directly, and his sister sat on the panel as a community representative. Much of the information was geared towards those less acquainted with the bureaucratic situation, as it has stood more-or-less unchanged for many months.
But one panelist, Dr. Marie Crandall of Northwestern, had some new information to share which has changed the timbre of the trauma center debate. Crandall shared with the audience the results of a forthcoming study she conducted which focused specifically on trauma facilities which receive a ‘high’ volume (> 40% of total cases) of gun- and knife-wound victims–a similar proportion of total trauma to what the South Side generates. Statistical analysis of this suggests that the link between geographic distance from trauma care and survival is not only intuitive in these cases but is likely actual; in her opinion, the sooner a facility is reached, the better. The state of Illinois currently requires trauma patients to be less than 30 minutes from a level 1 (i.e. 24-hour, surgery-ready) trauma center, but this law fails to take clinical differences within the designation of “traumatic injury” into account. Dr. Crandall concluded that a trauma center at UCMC, although it would incur about 15 million dollars in annual net losses, would save, on average, 7 lives a year.
With such a stark articulation, how UCMC chooses to proceed will be a judgement between the lives of seven South Side residents and a fifteen million dollar annual institutional loss. What is really at stake has now been made clear, but Dr. Crandall knows this information won’t bring any solutions on its own: “Is it worth it? I don’t know. I think that’s a philosophical question more than anything.”

